CASE TITLE: OGBUJI & ORS v. OGBONNA & ORS (2024) LPELR-62168(SC)
JUDGMENT DATE: 22ND MARCH, 2024
PRACTICE AREA: CIVIL PROCEDURE
LEAD JUDGMENT: UGOCHUKWU ANTHONY OGAKWU, J.C.A.
SUMMARY OF JUDGMENT:
INTRODUCTION:
This appeal borders on Civil Procedure.
FACTS:
This is an appeal by the Appellants against the judgment of the Court of Appeal, held at Owerri, wherein the Court allowed the appeal of the respondents at the Court below and set aside the judgment of the High Court which was in favour of the present appellants. Not satisfied with the decision, the appellants have appealed to this Court.
The facts that led to this appeal are that the appellants instituted an action seeking the following reliefs:
i) A Declaration that the decisions contained in the White Paper altering the agreement between the appellants and Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited and that between the appellants and other oil and gas companies in OWAZA were illegal, null and void, and against the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.
ii) A Declaration that the respondents are not competent to interfere with the agreement between the appellants and Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited and between appellants and other oil servicing companies with respect to the benefits of the appellants on account of the said agreement and to substitute an entirely different arrangement from the pre-existing contractual rights.
iii) An Injunction restraining the Respondents from further interfering with pre-existing agreements, and
iv) An Injunction restraining the respondents from further intimidating or unlawfully forcing Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria with the Appellants.
The undisputed facts at trial are that the appellants are members of Umuagalaba family in Isi-Etitioha Owaza in Ukwa West Local Government Area. In 1975, Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited (hereinafter referred to as “Shell”) commenced Oil exploration in Owaza Community. Shell entered into an agreement with these families to pay compensation for damages and rent on account of their exploration. Other oil servicing companies also entered into similar agreement with families in the community. This arrangement was truncated by the Civil War and it resumed after the Civil War. Around this period, the Owaza communities were divided into four autonomous communities viz Ipu West, Etitioha Ipu, Isi-Etitioha and Igiri-Ukwa. In 2002, following the creation of four new autonomous communities out of Owaza community, a government panel met with the leaders for compensation and utilization of communally owned amenities in the area to avert a breakdown of Law and Order. The panel submitted a report, which led to the issuing of a WHITE PAPER by the Government of Abia State on the way forward in the sharing of the amenities provided by Shell and its contractors.
The trial Court found the facts in favour of the appellants and granted the reliefs sought by them. The Court of Appeal, on appeal held that the appellants did not tender any agreement between them and Shell nor did the appellants tender the signature page of the White Paper for the two Courts below to determine who were signatories to the various meetings and the conclusion of the White Paper It allowed the appeal and held that a document not fully seen by the trial Court should not have been annulled. Hence this further appeal to the Supreme Court.
ISSUE(S) FOR DETERMINATION:
The Court considered:
DECISION/HELD:
The appeal was allowed by a majority decision. Ogunwumiju and Saulawa JJSC dissented.
RATIOS:
To read the full judgment or similar judgments, subscribe to Prime or Primsol
In the Supreme Court of Nigeria Holden at Abuja On Friday, the 1st Day of…
The acting Governor of Oyo State, Barr. Bayo Lawal, last Wednesday inaugurated the Rule of…
Introduction When you hear about document management systems, does Acrobat Reader or something close to…
CASE TITLE: TOTAL EXPLORATION & PRODUCTION (NIG) LTD v. OKWU & ORS (2024) LPELR-62623(SC) JUDGMENT…
CASE TITLE: NERC v. IBEDC LTD & ORS (2024) LPELR-62386(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 10TH JUNE, 2024…
CASE TITLE: GIDADO v. LAWAN (2024) LPELR-62724(CA)JUDGMENT DATE: 6TH AUGUST, 2024PRACTICE AREA: LAND LAWLEAD JUDGMENT:…