Categories: Be the FIRST to KNOW

WHETHER EXTRANEOUS MATTERS CAN BE USED TO MODIFY A WRITTEN AGREEMENT

If you find this case helpful and would like to access more cases like this, please subscribe to LawPavilion PRIME here

CASE TITLE: ANCHOR MARINE & OIL LTD v. ALUMINIUM SMELTER COMPANY OF NIGERIA (2019) LPELR-47209(CA)

JUDGMENT DATE: 12TH APRIL, 2019

PRACTICE AREA: CONTRACT

LEAD JUDGMENT: MUHAMMED LAWAL SHUAIBU, J.C.A.

SUMMARY OF JUDGMENT:

INTRODUCTION

This appeal borders on Law of Contract.

FACTS

The provenance of this appeal is in the contract between the parties whereby the respondent herein leased its properties and also supplied diesel to the appellant. The appellant on its part supplied crane services to the respondent. The respondent as plaintiff at the trial Court took out a Writ under the undefended list against the appellant and claimed as follows:-

(a) The sum of $171,582.76 (One Hundred and Seventy One Thousand, Five Hundred and Eighty-Two dollars, Seventy-Six Cents) or N26,639,937.37 (Twenty Six Million, Six Hundred and Thirty-Nine Thousand, Nine Hundred and Thirty-Seven Naira Thirty Seven Kobo @ N155,256 per dollar being:

(i) $165,848.63 (One Hundred and Sixty-Five Thousand, Eight Hundred and Forty-Eight Dollars, Sixty Three Cents) or Naira equivalent of N25,749,656.70 (Twenty Five Million, Seven Hundred and Forty-Nine Thousand Six Hundred and Fifty-Six Naira, Seventy Kobo @ N155,256 per dollar.

(ii) $1,576.48 or Naira equivalent of N244,765.00 per dollar, representing the supply of diesel as invoices.

(iii) $4,157.64 or Naira equivalent of N645,515.67 @ N155.256 per dollar.
(iv) 10% interest on the total amount until the same is paid.

The appellant as defendant filed a notice of intention to defend and based on which the case was transferred to the general cause list. Parties thereafter filed and exchanged pleadings. After the settlement of issues, the matter proceeded to trial.

At the end of the trial, in a reserved and considered judgment the learned trial judge entered judgment in favour of the respondent and granted the all reliefs claimed. The appellant being dissatisfied with the said judgment appealed against same.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

The appellant distilled two issues for determination as follows:-

  1. Whether from the totality of the evidence before the trial Court the respondent proved his case against the appellant and entitled to the claims awarded to him by the trial Court? (Distilled from grounds 1, additional grounds 1 and 2).
  2. Whether the suit at the trial Court was not an abuse of Court process? (Distilled from ground 3).

On its part, the respondent formulated a lone issue for the determination of the appeal thus:-

Whether the claimant/Respondent proved its case (in pleadings, evidence and documents) within the law at the trial Court against the appellant to be entitled to its claims?

DECISION/HELD

On the whole, the Court of Appeal held that the appeal lacked merit and it was dismissed.

RATIOS:

  • CONTRACT- WRITTEN CONTRACT: Whether extraneous matters can be used to modify a written agreement
  • EVIDENCE- EVALUATION OF EVIDENCE: Factors to be considered when evaluation of evidence is being challenged
  • EVIDENCE- WRITTEN STATEMENT ON OATH: Position of the law as regards an adopted written statement on oath
  • EVIDENCE- DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE: Effect of a document rejected in evidence
  • EVIDENCE- CONTRADICTION IN EVIDENCE: Instance where a piece of evidence will not be contradictory to another

lawpavilion

Recent Posts

5 Must-Have Skills for Lawyers to Succeed in 2025

Introduction The legal profession has always been known for its high standards and unique demands,…

1 day ago

Can the Court Impose a Willing Employee on an Unwilling Employer?

CASE TITLE: UNITY BANK PLC v. ALONGE (2024) LPELR-61898(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 4TH APRIL, 2024 JUSTICES:…

4 days ago

Whether it is Necessary to Have Corroboration in A Rape Trial

CASE TITLE: ODIONYE v. FRN (2024) LPELR-62923(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 5TH SEPTEMBER, 2024 PRACTICE AREA: CRIMINAL LAW…

4 days ago

Whether The Law on Limitation of Action Applies to Cases of Continuous Damage/Injury

CASE TITLE: EFFIONG v. MOBIL PRODUCING (NIG.) UNLTD (2024) LPELR-62930(CA)JUDGMENT DATE: 27TH SEPTEMBER, 2024PRACTICE AREA:…

4 days ago

Nature and Ingredients of The Offence of Criminal Trespass

CASE TITLE: ONWUSOR v. STATE (2024) LPELR-63031(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 12TH NOVEMBER, 2024 PRACTICE AREA: CRIMINAL…

4 days ago

Illegality of Charging Protesters with Terrorism and Treason

By Femi Falana SAN Introduction Last week, President Bola Tinubu ordered the immediate termination of…

4 days ago