What the Prosecution Must Prove in a Charge of Unlawful Possession of Firearms and Effect of Failure To Do So

CASE TITLE: STATE v. ISEH (2024) LPELR-62928(CA)
JUDGMENT DATE: 24TH SEPTEMBER, 2024
PRACTICE AREA: CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE
LEAD JUDGMENT: BALKISU BELLO ALIYU, J.C.A.

SUMMARY OF JUDGMENT:

INTRODUCTION:
This appeal borders on Criminal Law and Procedure.

FACTS:
This appeal is against the judgment of the High Court of Akwa Ibom State, Ikot Ekpene Judicial Division (trial Court), delivered on the 3rd of December 2020 by Hon. Justice Augustine D. Odokwo.

The case of the prosecution as per the evidence of PW3, who was the investigating police officer, was that upon receiving a petition complaining of unlawful possession of firearms against the respondent, he executed a search warrant in the respondent’s house and recovered one locally made gun and one live cartridge in his room. He tendered the gun he said he recovered, and it was admitted as exhibit 4 at the trial, along with the extrajudicial statement of the respondent admitted as exhibit 1 and the search warrant admitted as exhibit 3.

The respondent denied the charge and insisted that the gun recovered from the back of his house, which was an old, unusable one owned by his father, was not the same tendered by the appellant’s PW3 as exhibit 4. He testified as DW1 and called one witness, DW4, in defence of the charge.

After the trial, in a considered judgment, the learned trial Judge found that the prosecution failed to prove the third ingredient of the offence of unlawful possession of a firearm having failed to prove that exhibit 4 was the same gun recovered from the house of the respondent. His Lordship therefore proceeded to discharge and acquit the respondent of the charge.

The appellant was aggrieved with the judgment and appealed against same.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION:
The Court adopted the issues formulated by the appellant in the determination of the appeal, thus:

  1. Whether the learned trial Judge was right in holding that the Appellant had not proved the case of illegal possession of firearms against the Respondent beyond reasonable doubt.
  2. Whether the learned trial Judge was right in holding that the evidence of the Respondent’s witnesses with regards to exhibit 4, cast doubt on the mind of the Court to warrant the discharge and acquittal of the Respondent.

DECISION/HELD:
In the final analysis, the appeal was dismissed.

RATIOS:
APPEAL- OMNIBUS GROUND OF APPEAL: How to couch an omnibus ground of appeal in a criminal appeal
APPEAL- GROUND(S) OF APPEAL: Purpose of ground(s) of appeal
APPEAL- INTERFERENCE WITH FINDING(S) OF FACT(S): Attitude of appellate courts to findings of fact made by a lower court
CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE- UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF FIREARMS AND AMMUNITION: What the prosecution must prove in a charge of unlawful possession of firearms and effect of failure to do so
EVIDENCE- BURDEN OF PROOF/ONUS OF PROOF: On whom lies the burden of proof in criminal cases

To read the full judgment or similar judgments, subscribe to Prime or Primsol

lawpavilion

Recent Posts

Breaking Down NERC’s Revised Order on Unauthorized Access, Meter Tampering, and Bypass

INTRODUCTION The Nigerian Electricity Regulatory Commission (NERC) issued an Amended Order on Unauthorized Access, Meter…

1 day ago

You Owe? They Sell: Can a Mortgagee Sell a Mortgaged Property that is Subject of Litigation

CASE TITLE: SAVANNAH BANK PLC V. FAMAKINWA & ANOR LPELR-80721(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 10TH JANUARY, 2025 JUSTICES:…

1 day ago

Whether Statement of Account Is Sufficient Proof of Debts and Lodgments

CASE TITLE: ACCESS BANK v. BALINWO (2025) LPELR-81219(CA) JUDGMENT DATE:  29TH APRIL, 2025 PRACTICE AREA: BANKING…

1 day ago

Principles Guiding the Court in Making an Order of Retrial in a Criminal Matter

CASE TITLE:  IBRAHIM v. STATE (2025) LPELR-81329(SC) JUDGMENT DATE: 23RD MAY, 2025 PRACTICE AREA: CRIMINAL LAW…

1 day ago

Whether A Party that Alleges that An Election was Invalid Can at the Same Time Seek to  be Declared the Winner of that Election

CASE TITLE: ENABULELE & ANOR v. MONDAY & ORS (2025) LPELR-81266(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 29TH MAY,…

1 day ago

Benefits of AI-Powered Knowledge Management in Legal Firms

As legal teams grow and evolve, the risk of losing critical insights, especially when experienced…

2 days ago