Categories: Be the FIRST to KNOW

Position of the Law on the Right to Personal Liberty

CASE TITLE: NAMODA v. C.O.P ZAMFARA STATE COMMAND, GUSAU & ORS (2023) LPELR-60271(CA)

JUDGMENT DATE: 14TH APRIL, 2023

PRACTICE AREA: CONSTITUTIONAL LAW

LEAD JUDGMENT: MUHAMMED LAWAL SHUAIBU, J.C.A.

SUMMARY OF JUDGMENT:

INTRODUCTION:

This appeal borders on right to personal liberty.

.

FACTS:

This appeal is against the decision of the High Court of Zamfara State delivered by Hon. Justice B. M. Kucheri on 14th December, 2021.

The appellant was arrested together with one Yusuf Bala Dogo in Ruwan Baure, Mada Village in Gusau Local Government Area by Mobile operatives of Zamfara State police command and taken to Tudun wada police station on the allegation of being involved in the offence of conspiracy to commit armed robbery and armed robbery.

The appellant spent 13 days at the Tudun Wada police station before being transferred to the State Criminal Investigation Department (State CID) Gusau where he was also detained for 11 days. On 28th June, 2018, the appellant was eventually taken before the Chief Magistrate Court V, Gusau, after spending a total of 24 days in police custody.

At the Chief Magistrate Court, the appellant was remanded in prison custody because the Court lacks jurisdiction to try capital offences. The appellant remained in prison custody based on that remand order and no charge was filed against the appellant, let alone a trial of the alleged offence.

Consequently, the appellant filed an application for the enforcement of his right to personal liberty which was turned down by the High Court.

Dissatisfied with the decision of the High Court, the appellant appealed to the Court of Appeal.

ISSUES:

The Court of Appeal determined the appeal by adopting the lone issue formulated by the appellant which is:

“Whether or not the lower Court’s refusal to make any order for the release and/or enforcement of the appellant’s fundamental right to liberty was wrong and/or occasioned a miscarriage of justice to the appellant?”

DECISION/HELD:

In conclusion, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal.

RATIOS:

  • CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – BREACH OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS: When detention would amount to a breach of the fundamental right
  • CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – BREACH OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS: When detention would amount to a breach of the fundamental right
  • CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – RIGHT TO PERSONAL LIBERTY: Position of the law on the right to personal liberty of a suspect being held for a capital offence
  • EVIDENCE – BURDEN OF PROOF/ONUS OF PROOF: On whom lies the burden of proof in a fundamental right enforcement proceeding; when same will shift

Go to primsol.lawpavilion.com to read the full judgment.

lawpavilion

Recent Posts

5 Must-Have Skills for Lawyers to Succeed in 2025

Introduction The legal profession has always been known for its high standards and unique demands,…

2 days ago

Can the Court Impose a Willing Employee on an Unwilling Employer?

CASE TITLE: UNITY BANK PLC v. ALONGE (2024) LPELR-61898(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 4TH APRIL, 2024 JUSTICES:…

5 days ago

Whether it is Necessary to Have Corroboration in A Rape Trial

CASE TITLE: ODIONYE v. FRN (2024) LPELR-62923(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 5TH SEPTEMBER, 2024 PRACTICE AREA: CRIMINAL LAW…

5 days ago

Whether The Law on Limitation of Action Applies to Cases of Continuous Damage/Injury

CASE TITLE: EFFIONG v. MOBIL PRODUCING (NIG.) UNLTD (2024) LPELR-62930(CA)JUDGMENT DATE: 27TH SEPTEMBER, 2024PRACTICE AREA:…

5 days ago

Nature and Ingredients of The Offence of Criminal Trespass

CASE TITLE: ONWUSOR v. STATE (2024) LPELR-63031(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 12TH NOVEMBER, 2024 PRACTICE AREA: CRIMINAL…

5 days ago

Illegality of Charging Protesters with Terrorism and Treason

By Femi Falana SAN Introduction Last week, President Bola Tinubu ordered the immediate termination of…

5 days ago