Position of the Law on Challenge of Record of Appeal Regarding Service/Non-Service of Court Process

CASE TITLE: YAKASSAI & ORS v. UGBOR (2024) LPELR-62903(CA)

JUDGMENT DATE: 18TH NOVEMBER, 2024

PRACTICE AREAPRACTICE AND PROCEDURE

LEAD JUDGMENT: JOSEPH OLUBUNMI KAYODE OYEWOLE, J.C.A.

SUMMARY OF JUDGMENT:

INTRODUCTION:

This appeal borders on Civil Procedure.

FACTS:

This is in respect of an appeal against the judgment of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory, held at Abuja, delivered on the 14th of December, 2015 by ANENIH, J.

The Appellants as owners and landlords of the premises occupied by the Respondent had a disagreement with the Respondent on rent increment and payment. The Respondent alleging that his premises were illegally locked up, which led to loss of revenue and damage to his property, took out a writ of summons at the trial Court.

The parties joined issues via pleadings and at trial, the Respondent called four witnesses while the Appellant called a lone witness. After taking final addresses from the respective counsel for the contending parties, the learned trial Judge delivered a considered judgment as aforesaid on the 14th of December 2015, wherein he found in favour of the Respondent and granted his reliefs.

Displeased at this outcome, the Appellant appealed.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION:

The Court considered:

1. Whether the trial in the High Court is not a nullity in view of the lack of personal service of the writ of summons on the 1st Appellant in the trial Court.

2. Whether the trial at the High Court did not amount to a denial of a fair hearing of the Appellants’ application to reopen the case to call a fresh witness.

DECISION/HELD:

In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed.

RATIOS:

  • ACTION- PLEADINGS: Effect of uncontroverted averments in pleadings
  • APPEAL- GROUND(S) OF APPEAL: Effect of a ground of appeal from which no issue for determination is formulated
  • APPEAL- INTERFERENCE WITH THE EXERCISE OF DISCRETION: Attitude of appellate courts to the exercise of discretion made by a trial Court
  • APPEAL- APPEAL AGAINST INTERLOCUTORY RULING/FINAL DECISION: Time within which to appeal against an interlocutory decision; effect of failure to seek extension of time to appeal same when time has expired
  • CONSTITUTIONAL LAW- RIGHT TO FAIR HEARING: Fundamental nature of the right to fair hearing and effect of breach of same
  • PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE- SERVICE OF COURT PROCESS(ES): Importance of service of Court process(es)
  • PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE- SERVICE OF COURT PROCESS(ES): Position of the law on challenge of record of appeal regarding service/non-service of court process
  • PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE- CONSISTENCY IN PRESENTATION OF A CASE: Whether a party must be consistent in the presentation of his case

To read the full judgment or similar judgments, subscribe to Prime or Primsol

lawpavilion

Recent Posts

Third Party Investigations and Six-Year Limit for Tax Assessments

INTRODUCTION The tax investigation involving Lafarge Africa Plc (Lafarge) and the Ogun State Internal Revenue…

1 month ago

Is Workplace Promotion a Privilege or a Right?

CASE TITLE: PHILIP v. ADSU, MUBI & ORS (2025) LPELR-81492(CA)JUDGMENT DATE: 26TH JUNE, 2025JUSTICES: FREDERICK…

1 month ago

Whether a Class of Persons Can Be Defamed; Duty on a Person Within That Class Who Intends to Maintain an Action for Defamation

CASE TITLE: ACCESS BANK PLC v. EDIALE (2025) LPELR-81868(CA) JUDGMENT DATE:  22ND JULY, 2025 PRACTICE…

1 month ago

Whether an Area Court Has Jurisdiction to Distribute the Estate of A Deceased Muslim who Contracted both a Statutory Marriage and an Islamic Marriage

CASE TITLE: ADEKUNLE & ORS v. AHMAD (2025) LPELR-81978(CA) JUDGMENT DATE: 3RD SEPTEMBER, 2025 PRACTICE…

1 month ago

NDP Act 2023 GAID 2025: A Comprehensive Guide to Nigeria’s New Data Protection Landscape

The Nigeria Data Protection Commission (NDPC) On March 20, 2025 issued the Nigeria Data Protection…

1 month ago

Court May Enforce, Not Set Aside, Foreign Award

CASE TITLE: OIL & INDUSTRIAL SERVICES LTD v. HEMPEL PAINTS (SOUTH AFRICA) PTY LTD (2025)…

1 month ago