Categories: Be the FIRST to KNOW

Need for Courts to be Brief While Ruling on a No Case Submission

CASE TITLE: NZERIBE v. FRN

JUDGMENT DATE: 18TH JANUARY, 2023

PRACTICE AREA: CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE

LEAD JUDGMENT: DANLAMI ZAMA SENCHI, J.C.A.

SUMMARY OF JUDGMENT:

INTRODUCTION:

This appeal borders on no case submission.

FACTS:

The Appellant (as Defendant) at the trial Court was arraigned before the trial Court on three count charges centred around forgery and false pretence surrounding a document/certificate of occupancy dated 4tn July, 1994 bearing the name of Ishaya M. Baba. Subsequently, the three-count charge was amended and filed on 5th October, 2021.

The Appellant pleaded not guilty to the amended charge.

Then on the 28th January, 2021, the trial began and the Respondent called five (5) witnesses that testified.

At the close of evidence by the Respondent, the case was adjourned for defence on 25th February, 2021. On the said date, instead of the Appellant entering his defence, he filed a no case to answer.

On the 16th of June, 2021, the trial Court delivered its ruling on the no case to answer and the same was dismissed. Aggrieved with the decision of the trial Court, the Appellant lodged an appeal at the Court of Appeal. At the Court of Appeal, the Respondent raised a preliminary objection on the competency of the Appellant’s notice of appeal. Respondent contended that the Appellant relied on the old charge to appeal against the ruling delivered by the trial Court refusing the no-case submission application filed by the Appellant.

ISSUES:

The Court of Appeal considered the merits of the preliminary objection filed by the Respondent.

The main appeal was determined on a sole issue thus:

“Whether having regards to the evidence adduced by the Respondent vis-a-vis the contents of the charge proffered against the Appellant, the trial Court was right to have dismissed the Appellant’s No Case Submission?”

DECISION/HELD:

On the whole, the preliminary objection succeeded and thus, the appeal was struck out. On the merits, the appeal was dismissed.

RATIOS:

  • CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE- AMENDMENT OF CHARGE: Effect of amendment of a charge
  • CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE- NO CASE SUBMISSION: What a no case submission entails/postulates
  • CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE- NO CASE SUBMISSION: Need for Courts to be brief while ruling on a no-case submission
  • EVIDENCE- PRIMA FACIE CASE: Meaning of prima facie case

Login or subscribe via primsol.lawpavilion.com to read the full judgment

lawpavilion

Recent Posts

Pretrial Issues Under The Administration of Criminal Justice Law 2015 – Reform & Recommendations (Part 1)

BY LYDIA EHISUORIA OHONSI The Lagos State Administration of Criminal Justice Law (ACJL) 2015 addresses…

4 days ago

Health Care Fraud and Abuse: A Growing Concern

INTRODUCTION Health care fraud and abuse are growing concerns globally, particularly in Nigeria, where millions…

4 days ago

Whether a Sitting Governor and a Commissioner of Police Can be Sued for Violation of Fundamental Rights in Nigeria

By Abubakar Muhammad The Constitutional Framework of Fundamental Rights The 1999 Constitution of the Federal…

4 days ago

Third Party Investigations and Six-Year Limit for Tax Assessments

INTRODUCTION The tax investigation involving Lafarge Africa Plc (Lafarge) and the Ogun State Internal Revenue…

1 week ago

Is the Plea of Allocutus a Right or a Privilege in Nigerian Criminal Proceedings?

By way of introduction, the term allocutus is derived from the classical Latin word allocutio…

1 week ago

The New Face of Post-Incorporation Process for Companies at the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) in Nigeria

By Hyginus Ibega Esq. The Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) has recently introduced new measures for…

1 week ago